40 Colonel Butler Dr
Sherwood-Amberglen, Markham, Ontario L3P 6B4
- Bedrooms
- 4
- Bathrooms
- 3
- Size
- 2,500–3,000sq ft
- Per sq ft
- $581at the range’s middle
- Lot
- 40.03 x 218 ft
- Tax a year
- $6,9192025 tax year
- Parking
- 42 attached
- Days on market
- Members
The brief
About 40 Colonel Butler Dr
40 Colonel Butler Dr is a 4-bedroom, 3-bathroom detached house in Sherwood-Amberglen, Markham, listed for sale at an asking price of $1,598,000 (MLS® N13851020).
Welcome to 40 Colonel Butler Drive, tucked away in the established and highly sought-after Sherwood-Amberglen community of Markham. Set on an exceptional 40 x 218 ft lot surrounded by mature trees, this spacious 2-storey brick home offers over 2,650 sq. ft. above grade, a finished lower level and a spectacular backyard retreat with an inground pool. Inside, the generous main-floor layout offers plenty of room to gather, entertain and simply enjoy everyday life. Formal living and dining rooms are complemented by a spacious kitchen with centre island, stainless steel appliances and a walkout to the backyard, while the family room features a gas fireplace, bow window and views of the beautiful outdoor setting. Main-floor laundry with direct garage access adds everyday convenience. Upstairs, the impressive primary retreat measures approximately 19 x 17 ft and overlooks the pool, with a 5-piece ensuite and an exceptionally large walk-in dressing room. Additional bedrooms provide comfortable space for family, guests or a home office. The finished lower level adds even more versatility with an expansive recreation room, wine cellar, walk-in closet and abundant storage. And then there is the backyard. With a lot extending approximately 218 ft deep, this is outdoor space that is increasingly hard to find in Markham. Mature trees and established landscaping create a private, leafy setting around the inground pool, with generous patio and lounging areas for summer entertaining, dining and relaxing. Located in Sherwood-Amberglen, an established neighbourhood known for its mature streetscapes and access to parks and green space, you're minutes from Main Street Markham, the Rouge Valley trail system, Milne Dam Conservation Park, Markham Stouffville Hospital, shopping, dining, transit and major commuter routes. A substantial family home, an extraordinary lot and a backyard built for summer - all in one of Markham's established communities.
Insights
Condition Score
Good68/1006 condition-related facts documented
Source: Listing age, structured features and disclosed update language; not an inspection.
Cashflow Quality
Shortfall7/100−$4,168/mo against the cost of owning (20% down, 4.8%, 25 yrs)
Source: Median of 43 detached homes with 4 bedrooms for lease in Markham right now. Cost of owning counts the mortgage and property tax.
Condition uses listing-record signals, not an inspection.
The home
Key facts
- Tax
- $6,919 / 2025
- MLS® number
- N13851020
- Board
- TRREB MLS®
- Property Type
- Detached
- Days on market
- Size
- 2500-3000 sqft
- Lot Size
- 40.03 x 218 ft
- Listed on
- Parking
- 2 Attached, 4 Parking
Property details
Property
- Property Type
- Detached
- Style
- 2-Storey
- Community
- Sherwood-Amberglen
- Municipality
- Markham
Building
- Size
- 2500-3000 sqft
- Construction
- Brick
Inside
- Bedrooms
- 4
- Bathrooms
- 3
- Bathroom Details
- 1 × 2pc Main, 1 × 4pc 2nd, 1 × 5pc 2nd
- Basement Type
- Full
- Kitchens
- 1
Parking
- Driveway
- Pvt Double
- Garage Type
- Attached
- Garage
- 2
- Additional Parking
- 2
- Total Parking
- 4
Utilities
- Water
- Municipal
- Cooling
- Central Air
- Heating Type
- Forced Air
Land
- Sewer
- Sewers
- Frontage
- 40.03 ft
- Depth
- 218 ft
- Lot Size
- 40.03 x 218 ft
Additional
- Foundation
- Concrete
- Roof
- Asphalt Shingle
- Fireplace
- Yes
- Pool
- Inground
- Den
- Yes
- Family room
- Yes
- Extras
- All ELFS, Stainless steel fridge, stove, dishwasher, over the range hood, built-in microwave, washer, dryer, shed, pergola, pool and existing equipment, central vacuum and existing equipment.
Rooms
| Room | Size | Features | Level |
|---|---|---|---|
| Living | 3.7 × 3.87 m | hardwood floor, Formal Rm, Pot Lights | Main |
| Dining | 4.3 × 3.87 m | hardwood floor, Combined W/Living, Pot Lights | Main |
| Kitchen | 6.58 × 3.87 m | Centre Island, W/O To Pool, Stainless Steel Appl | Main |
| Family | 5.91 × 4.15 m | Fireplace, Bow Window, Pot Lights | Main |
| Laundry | 2.56 × 1.93 m | W/O To Garage, Laundry Sink | Main |
| Primary | 5.37 × 5.8 m | hardwood floor, O/Looks Pool | 2nd |
| 2nd Br | 3.54 × 3.87 m | W/I Closet, hardwood floor | 2nd |
| 3rd Br | 4.39 × 4.81 m | Hardwood Floor | Upper |
| 4th Br | 4.39 × 3.19 m | Hardwood Floor | 2nd |
| Rec | 6.48 × 8.12 m | — | Bsmt |
| Other | 2.56 × 2.29 m | — | Bsmt |
| Utility | 7.34 × 3.87 m | — | Bsmt |
Listing history
Buy/sell history for 40 Colonel Butler Dr, Markham, Ontario
Sale history on this site covers the last 2 years, the window permitted under the TRREB MLS® VOW agreement.
Dates and closing prices are shown to signed-in members.
| Date Start | Date End | List Price | Price | Event | Listing ID |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Date Start— | — | $1,598,000 | — | Pc | N13851020 |
Members see the full history. Prices are hidden from signed-out visitors.
The numbers
Mortgage Calculator
Plan with the current asking price
CMHC insurance: not required at 20% down. Payments use Canadian semi-annual compounding.
Mortgage Details
4.8% · 5-year term · 25-year amortization · 20% down
- Total down payment
- $319,600
- Total mortgage amount
- $1,278,400
- Total interest payment
- $908,900
- Total purchase cost
- $2,506,900
- Mortgage payment
- $7,291/mo
Cash Flow Analysis
If you rented this home out at 20% down
Break-even down payment
66%Monthly carrying cost
$7,868- Rent $3,700
- Shortfall $4,168
Rental income opens at $3,700, the median asking rent of 43 comparable homes for lease in Markham. Type over it with the rent you expect. This is a planning tool, not advice.
Land transfer tax on this home
- Ontario land transfer tax
- $28,435
- Total land transfer tax
- $28,435
- First-time buyer rebates (Ontario up to $4,000)
- −$4,000
- Total for first-time buyers
- $24,435
See how this is worked out
- 0.5% on the first $55,000
- $275
- 1.0% from $55,000 to $250,000
- $1,950
- 1.5% from $250,000 to $400,000
- $2,250
- 2.0% from $400,000 to $1,598,000
- $23,960
- Ontario total
- $28,435
An estimate at the asking price, for a home with one or two single-family residences. Your lawyer confirms the exact amount.
Estimate
Estimated value requires sign in
Market estimates use sold comparables and are available after you sign in and accept MLS® VOW terms.
The estimate is an automated value built from public and MLS® data. It is not an appraisal; ask The Campbell-Maric Group for a full comparative market analysis.
Comparable sales
Comparable sales require sign in
Closing prices and sold comps are available to registered visitors who accept MLS® VOW terms on this site.
The market
Detached homes for sale in Sherwood-Amberglen right now
- For sale now
- 8
- Median asking price
- $1.37M
Middle half: $1.17M to $1.52M
This home is asking 17% above the median, higher than three quarters of them.
See all homes in Sherwood-AmberglenAsking prices and counts of the MLS® listings on this site as of today. Asking figures only, never sold or leased prices.
Market area · filters apply to the charts below
The street
Map and tour
Transit nearby
| Station | Lines | Distance |
|---|---|---|
| Highway 7 / Wootten | YRT bus rapid transit: Viva Purple | 800 m |
| Cornell Bus Terminal | YRT bus rapid transit: Viva Purple | 1.2 km |
| Markham Stouffville Hospital | YRT bus rapid transit: Viva Purple | 1.5 km |
| Highway 7 / Main Markham | YRT bus rapid transit: Viva Purple | 1.8 km |
| Markham GO | GO Transit train: Stouffville | 2.3 km |
The nearest subway, light rail, train, bus rapid transit stations 5 km, as the crow flies. Source: GO Transit schedule data (GTFS) from Metrolinx under the Open Government Licence – Ontario – Metrolinx; YRT schedule data (GTFS) from York Region Transit under the YRT Open Data Licence 2.0, downloaded October 18, 2026. Data used in this product or service is provided with the permission of Metrolinx. Metrolinx makes no representations or warranties of any kind, express or implied, with respect to the Data and assumes no responsibility for the accuracy or currency of the data used in this product or service. Contains information licensed under the Open Government Licence – Ontario – Metrolinx. Contains public transit Information made available under YRT's Open Data Licence.
Schools nearby
| Elementary | Type | Distance | EQAO average 2024–25 |
|---|---|---|---|
| William Armstrong Public SchoolYork Region DSB | Public · grades JK–8 | 500 m | 84%Grade 6 average |
| Legacy Public SchoolYork Region DSB | Public · grades JK–8 | 850 m | 88%Grade 6 average |
| Sir Richard W Scott Catholic Elementary SchoolYork CDSB | Catholic · grades JK–8 | 1.6 km | 93%Grade 6 average |
| École élémentaire Laure-RièseConseil scolaire Viamonde | French-language public · grades JK–6 | 6.3 km | 88%Grade 6 average |
| Secondary | Type | Distance | Grade 9 math 2024–25 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Markham District High SchoolYork Region DSB | Public · grades 9–12 | 1.4 km | 77%Grade 9 math |
| Bill Hogarth Secondary SchoolYork Region DSB | Public · grades 9–12 · French Immersion | 2.5 km | 78%Grade 9 math |
| St Brother André Catholic High SchoolYork CDSB | Catholic · grades 9–12 · French Immersion | 3 km | 69%Grade 9 math |
| Middlefield Collegiate InstituteYork Region DSB | Public · grades 9–12 | 3.6 km | 72%Grade 9 math |
EQAO: share of students at or above the provincial standard, 2024–25 (Ontario open data). These are the schools nearest this home, not the schools it is assigned to: boundaries change, and some schools take students by application. Confirm with the board before you buy. Contains information licensed under the Open Government Licence – Ontario.
The verdict
Similar Active Listings
Recently sold nearby
Sold prices in Sherwood-Amberglen are shown to signed-in members.

